Working Papers

Dynamic Consistency of Multidimensional and Income Targeting: An Application for Mexico Using Panel Data Information

AUTHOR(s): Yañez-Pagans, Patricia
PUBLISHED: March 2011
RELATED TOPICS: Poverty Reduction and Labor


This paper compares the dynamic consistency of targeting methodologies that use multidimensional welfare indicators with those based on means and proxy means tests using panel data from Mexico. To make these comparisons, an extension of the Alkire and Foster (2008) dual cutoff multidimensional poverty methodology is proposed. This extension provides a relative approach to multidimensional deprivation that ranks individuals according to an aggregate of their relative position in the distribution of a set of welfare attributes or outcomes. The extension gives particular importance to deprivations that affect smaller portions of the population, as these deprivations are especially critical in defining relative multidimensional welfare. The findings, disaggregated by geographical area (urban and rural), suggest that taking into account deprivation in multiple dimensions may lead to more dynamically consistent measures of well-being and thus more dynamically consistent targeting algorithms.

Related Research by JEL Codes:
(or click here to find research by JEL Codes)
  • Low-Income Housing Finance in Colombia
    Working Papers
    IDB-WP-256 - August 2011

    Using the Quality of Life Surveys conducted in Colombia in 2003 and 2008, this study finds that policy instruments aimed at easing low-income households’ access to affordable housing such as subsidies and loan guarantees have played a modest role in increasing the use of mortgages as a source of funding. Despite this, subsidies have had a significant impact on both the quality of dwelling and the ... (View publication)

  • Ideas for Development in the Americas (IDEA), Volume 38: September-December, 2015: The Big Job of Raising Little Kids
    Newsletter / Journal
    IDB-NW-165 - December 2015

    This issue of IDEA examines some of the issues surrounding early childhood development in Latin America and the Caribbean, and why government should be involved in what would seem to be a family affair. It draws on the 2015 edition of the IDB’s flagship series, Development in the Americas, entitled The Early Years: Child Well-Being and the Role of Public Policy, by Samuel Berlinski and Norbert Sch ... (View publication)

  • The Early Years: Child Well-being and the Role of Public Policy (Synopsis)
    IDB-BR-181 - October 2015

    This synopsis reviews the arguments in favor of a larger role for public policy in determining the well-being of young children. It explains where the region is in terms of child well-being today, how it should go about improving public programs, and the institutional challenges to implementing those programs. Together, this synopsis and the table of contents provide just a taste of the rich ... (View publication)

Hello, Welcome to the IDB!

Please join our mailing list by simply entering your email below.